Let’s talk money! Especially, Fixed Accounting Fees! We all want to save a few dollars, especially us small and medium-sized business owners down under. Every dollar counts. So, when an accountant or lawyer offers a fixed fee package, it’s tempting, right? Sounds like a good deal. Predictable costs, no nasty surprises, budget sorted.
Now, I’m not here to completely bash fixed fee arrangements – we use them ourselves, and they can be helpful for clients to spread their accounting costs over the year instead of facing one large bill at the end. But I also can’t simply accept that fixed fees are this miracle solution that will save your business heaps compared to hourly billing.
Fixed fees: The ‘too good to be true’ trap
I’m here to spill the beans. I’m not saying fixed fees are always bad. For one-off projects, they can be a lifesaver. But when it comes to ongoing services like small business accounting? That’s where things get murky. And that’s when you need to carefully weigh up the pros and cons of fixed fee accounting vs hourly billing.
Myth-busting time
Let’s clear up a few misconceptions:
- “Fixed fees save me money”: Not necessarily. Accountants and lawyers have internal hourly rates, whether they tell you or not. That fixed fee? It’s calculated based on those rates, plus a little buffer for unexpected work. There are often hidden costs of fixed fee accounting that can catch you off guard.
- “I know what I’m paying for”: Sure, you know the upfront cost. But what happens when you need something extra? An urgent consultation? A complex tax situation? Boom, additional charges. That “fixed” fee just got a lot less fixed.
- “My accountant will be more efficient & proactive”: Maybe, maybe not. Imagine your accountant spots a potential tax saving opportunity or a looming financial risk. If it’s not covered in your fixed fee agreement, they might hesitate to contact you about it. After all, it means more work for them, but no extra pay. With hourly billing, they’re more likely to be proactive, because their time is valued.
The hidden cost of fixed fees
Ever heard of scope creep? It’s the silent killer of fixed fee agreements. It’s when your project expands beyond its original boundaries. And trust me, it happens all the time.
Here’s the thing: when you have a fixed fee, you might feel like you’re getting a bargain. So, you might start making more requests, asking for extra reports, or seeking advice on things that weren’t initially included. Before you know it, your accountant is doing a whole lot more work for the same price. And guess what? They’re not happy about it.
The psychology of pricing
Now, let’s talk a bit about how those sneaky fixed fees can play tricks on your mind. It’s all about marketing psychology. You know how they say there’s a difference between paying $2 flat and $1.99? It’s virtually the same amount, but that $1.99 just feels like a better deal.
It’s the same with accounting fees. Which sounds better to you: a $5,500 including GST bill at the end of the financial year, or a monthly fee of $416.67 plus GST?
Spoiler alert: they add up to the same amount! But that monthly fee might feel more manageable, even though it’s essentially the same cost spread out over the year.
Fixed fees are often presented in a way that uses this kind of marketing psychology to make them seem more appealing. Look at the total cost, not just the way it’s presented.
The hourly billing advantage
Now, let’s talk about the good old-fashioned hourly billing. I know, it doesn’t sound as sexy. But hear me out. Hourly billing offers a level of transparency that fixed fees just can’t match.
- Transparency: With hourly billing, you see exactly where your money is going. Each invoice breaks down the time spent on each task. No hidden costs.
- Flexibility: Need a quick consultation? No problem. Just pay for the time it takes. Your accounting needs fluctuate? Hourly billing adjusts accordingly. You only pay for what you use. This is especially important for growing businesses whose accounting needs can change rapidly.
- Proactive service: With hourly billing, your accountant is more likely to reach out if they see an opportunity or a problem, even if it’s not strictly within the initial scope of work. They know their time will be valued.
Okay, I’ll admit, I might have been a tad passionate in this blog post. For a more objective analysis on fixed vs. hourly billing, check out this article from Xero.
But won’t my accountant take longer if they’re billing hourly?
This is a valid question, and probably a crucial one. The way I see it, if you don’t trust someone to do an honest job and bill for the time it actually takes, then are they really the right person to be your trusted advisor?
This is an ongoing relationship. Should I value this client by making sure I charge them an appropriate amount and keep them for the foreseeable future? Or should I risk short-term gain by inflating my fees by say 10%? I’ll always choose the first option.
There’s absolutely nothing wrong with asking your accountant for a fee estimate before proceeding with tasks that could take a significant amount of time.
Making the right choice for your business
So, which billing structure is right for you? Well, it depends. If you have a simple, predictable accounting situation, a fixed fee might work. But if your business is growing, changing, or has complex needs, hourly billing is probably the safer bet.
Remember, the cost of accountant fees for small businesses can add up. So, it’s crucial to choose the right billing structure that offers both transparency and flexibility. Don’t get seduced by the siren song of fixed fees without understanding the potential downsides.
Your accountant is your partner in business. Choose a billing structure that fosters a transparent, flexible, and mutually beneficial relationship. And don’t be afraid to ask questions! A good accountant will be happy to explain their fees and help you choose the right accounting billing structure for your business.
Need a top-notch Small & Medium Size Business accountant? You can explore our other services here.
